Outline the arguments against the dependency of morality on worship (21)
find out the view that these arguments be outweighed by the claim that morality is babelike on religion (9)
The link between morality and religion has been discussed for many centuries and there are a variety of discussions. not all people would argue that morality is dependent on religion and there are many arguments to support this.
The number one argument to suggest that morality isnt dependant on religion came from Plato in the Euthyphro Dilemma.
The Euthyphro Dilemma is the question posed by Socrates to Plato in Platos Euthyphro and is the question as to whether or not theology is the creator of heavyness and morality or whether they are independent to him and he secure passes it on to humans: Does God command X because it is safe or is X best because God commands it?
In this question there are cardinal horns, the first one is; Does God command X because it is good? This is suggesting that commodity already exists as something separate to God, and God is only(prenominal) needed to make this a moral command. God is the marrow by which man receives moral knowledge, but that knowledge has not suffice influencely from Gods morally good nature.
This quote means that God is not wholly good, he only receives the goodness, and just passes it onto man. This therefore supports the idea that morality isnt dependant on religion because if God was Omniscient consequently he would already know what is good. Therefore God bedt be the main form of moral goodness as he himself isnt good, hes just the passenger, and just conforms the goodness. Meaning morality is dependent on religion.
The second gear horn to the Euthyphro dilemma is; Is X good because God commands it? This get out of the question suggests that there is no doubt that God is the direct source of any moral knowledge, and that morality doesnt come directly from Gods morally good nature. This model supports the Divine Command Theory as God commands what is...If you require to get a full essay, order it on our website: Orderessay
If you want to get a full essay, wisit our page: write my essay .
No comments:
Post a Comment